Security
Four Firms, Four Mercado Bitcoin Loss Figures, and Two Weeks Without a Cause From the Exchange
Brazil’s largest crypto exchange froze withdrawals on November 2 after its hot wallets were drained. Hypernative, Arkham, Bitquery and Chainalysis each put a number on it, from more than $40 million to about $49 million. The exchange has confirmed none of them, and reporting through November 10 still had no account of how the attackers got in.
On November 2, Mercado Bitcoin, Brazil’s largest crypto exchange, said on X that it had contained a security incident and suspended deposits and withdrawals as a precaution. According to Bitbo’s account of that post, only hot wallets were affected, most assets sit in offline cold storage, customers will not lose assets, and no customer data leaked. Two weeks later the incident has at least four published loss figures. None comes from the exchange.
Four numbers for one drain
The earliest figure came from Hypernative, a blockchain security firm, which flagged more than $40 million in suspicious transfers across at least 10 chains, including Bitcoin, Ethereum, Solana and Tron. The same day, Protos quoted an Arkham analyst, Emmett Gallic, putting losses above $46 million and growing; Protos also said the exchange had shared the wallet addresses where the funds went. By November 4, Cointelegraph was writing “more than $46 million,” attributed to blockchain analysts.
Bitbo’s account adds two more. Bitquery, a blockchain data firm, is reported to have counted $48.6 million taken across 10 blockchains. Chainalysis is reported to have put it at about $49 million across 17 blockchains, with the largest tranches from Bitcoin and Ethereum. By November 10 Cointelegraph was repeating “an estimated $49 million,” without saying whose estimate it was.
Who put what number on the Mercado Bitcoin drain
| Source | Figure | Chains |
|---|---|---|
| Hypernative | More than $40M | At least 10 |
| Arkham analyst, via Protos | More than $46M, growing | Not stated |
| Bitquery | $48.6M | 10 |
| Chainalysis | About $49M | 17 |
| Mercado Bitcoin | No total published | Not stated |
The spread, from just over $40 million to about $49 million, is about 20 percent. Two things plausibly explain it, and neither is confirmed. The firms may have counted different sets of wallets: Bitquery’s 10 chains against Chainalysis’s 17 is the obvious difference. And the drain was still running when the early numbers were published. Bitbo says Bitquery reported that outflows continued for about four hours after the exchange said the incident was contained. A figure taken at 9 a.m. and one taken that afternoon would differ even if everyone counted the same wallets.
24/7 Wall St. says Mercado Bitcoin declined to confirm Hypernative’s figure and has not published a verified account of its losses. Cointelegraph’s November 4 piece likewise gives no company-confirmed total. This desk found none either.
Hot wallets and deposit addresses
The exchange said hot wallets. The analysts describe something wider. Cointelegraph’s November 4 account says attackers moved funds from the company’s hot wallets and customer deposit addresses through standard transfers. Gallic told Protos that old deposit addresses were being swept and that the attacker was selling memecoins and altcoins. Bitbo relays Bitquery as counting 36,042 customer deposit addresses emptied on Ethereum alone.
A deposit address is the per-customer address an exchange issues for incoming transfers, and the exchange controls what is in it. That is why the two descriptions need not conflict: funds sitting in customer deposit addresses can be exchange-held balances rather than customers’ own wallets. But the sources do not say so, and this desk is not going to supply the reconciliation. What is on the record is that the exchange’s description and the analysts’ differ in scope, and the exchange has not addressed the gap.
What has been frozen, and what has not been said
Freezing started within hours. Bitbo says Mercado Bitcoin reported about $11 million blocked with help from Tether, Circle, BRL1, Paxos and Chainalysis, and that Tether’s chief executive, Paolo Ardoino, said Tether froze more than 4.5 million USDT tied to the incident. By November 4, Cointelegraph quoted the company’s statement putting frozen funds at more than $15 million. The November 10 Cointelegraph piece gives no frozen figure at all, so the current amount is not on the record in the sources this desk read.
Nobody has been named as the attacker. Bitbo’s account refers only to an unidentified hacker. Mercado Bitcoin’s failure to link the incident to anything else matters here, because the breach landed days after the roughly $6.3 billion Binance theft, which the FBI attributed to North Korea’s TraderTraitor group. Some outlets mention the two together. The sources this desk read contain no evidence tying them, and the exchange has not made the connection.
As for cause, there is nothing. Cointelegraph’s November 10 article says the exchange’s site points to security measures and audits “since 2018” and offers no account of the attack. 24/7 Wall St. says the exchange has not explained how the attackers reached its wallets. No outlet this desk found reports a root cause, a vulnerable system or a compromised credential. That is not unusual two weeks in. It is still the question that decides how worried other Brazilian users should be, and the answer is not public.
The recovery plan
The exchange has said what it will do about the money. According to Cointelegraph’s November 4 report, it will use company funds to replenish affected assets, and its trading desk is “preparing to begin the necessary repurchases in domestic and international markets.” It cited a $20 million investment from Tether and its cash position as support for liquidity. The same article never gives a total cost of coverage, and notes the gap between the analysts’ loss estimate and the company’s own frozen-funds figure.
Access is returning in stages. Read-only account access began November 9. A company representative told Cointelegraph that Brazilian-real deposits and withdrawals through Pix would resume “next week,” only to accounts in the customer’s own name. Crypto deposits and withdrawals stay suspended with no date, and Cointelegraph noted that no rollout schedule appears on the exchange’s website. The representative said resumption “will proceed gradually.”
The Take
Four credible firms disagreeing by a few million dollars is normal; the exchange’s silence on the total is the part worth noticing. A company that promises to make every customer whole has to know the number it is making whole, and it knows its own wallets better than any outside tracer. Until Mercado Bitcoin publishes a total and a cause, the $40 million to $49 million range is analysts’ arithmetic, and “customers will not lose assets” is a promise nobody can yet check.